Thai Curry Episode VII: Advance Authentic Thai Red Curry Paste, Kaeng Panang, Kaeng ChuChee, Kaeng Phed and Jungle Curry Paste

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste

I’m starting to feel like I have been neglecting Thai curry as a subject, but it’s summertime and I want to eat light food and all the fresh produce available around here in California more than eating curry. Anyhow, I got a request to make Choo Chee curry, so I think I’ll use this as an appropriate re-entry. After all, it’s after Labor Day, despite the fact that in Manhattan Beach the summer has just begun, if you are talking about temperature.

To make a proper Thai curry, the first thing you need is curry paste. I already gave you the recipe for Kaeng Kua curry paste which is the basis for most red curries. I told you then that I would explain later how to transform the Kaeng Kua to other curry pastes.

Also, I just want to tell you that, to Thai household right before the curry paste revolution (when people start using pre-made or store bought curry paste), curry paste is a signature of the house. If you know the Thai language and can look up recipes of curry pastes on the internet, you would  discover that curry paste recipes are almost like bread recipes in their variation.

The way I do this is obviously not traditional, but it works for me because I can’t always go pull lemongrass out the ground (even though I can do it right now) or dig up the galangal root to make fresh curry paste every time I make a curry. I can’t even go to the corner grocery store and ask to buy lemongrass the way I would do in Thailand either.

My simple solution is to make the most basic curry paste, containing the least ingredients, which is Kaeng Kua, then I can add other ingredients to it to transform it into other curry pastes.

So, how to do it?

Kaeng Kua is the curry paste without “spices”. You might want to laugh; what about all the garlic, shallots, lemongrass, galangal, coriander root, Kaffir lime zest, etc…? Well, we do not consider them spices. The ingredients that the Thais would consider as “spice” are cumin, coriander seed, nutmeg, mace, cinnamon, cloves, cardamom, bay leaves and star anise.

Kaeng Kua has none of these spices.

Kaeng Choo Chee also has none of these, but it has roasted coconut and white peppercorn mixed in with the Kaeng Kua base.

Kaeng Phed and Kaeng Pa (Jungle curry) have coriander seeds and cumin and white peppercorn mixed in with the Kaeng Kua base, but Kaeng Pa has more fresh chili add on to the curry paste.

Kaeng Panang not only has coriander seeds, cumin and white peppercorn mixed in with the Kaeng Kua base but also has roasted peanuts .

Do you see now why I make a big batch of Kaeng Kua?

You probably still want to know exactly how to do it?

You just mush the extra ingredients in mortar first, and add Kaeng Kua curry paste into it. How simple, isn’t it? Oh…oh…not so fast.

You have to roast all of the spices before you add them in the mortar.

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 6

Couldn’t you just make the curry paste all at once from scratch?

Sure you can. I do that sometimes too. These days I don’t use a mortar and pestle to make my curry paste as much. It takes longer and I normally have to sit on the floor with my mortar because I can get more power to pound on the ingredients, but I have a very curious cat and dog. Can you picture them sitting around my mortar to watch me, with all their hairs and drools?

I can’t use my Vitamix to make a small batch of curry paste either. I only need about 1/4 cup of curry paste to make a pot of curry for two, but with Vitamix I would have to make at least a cup to cover the blades and ensure the flow. In that case I like to make a batch of Kaeng Kua curry paste and convert it to other curry pastes later.

I also like to have Kaeng Kua curry paste in the fridge just in case I need curry paste in a heartbeat but don’t have time to run to the market to buy ingredients. Plus Kaeng Kua is the curry paste that is widely used in many recipes, but Chu Chee or Panaeng are quite specific.

How specific?

Let’s introduce you to Kaeng Panang and Kaeng Choo Chee.

First, their similarity. Both are “gravy-like” rather than “soup-like” curries, meaning they don’t have a lot of liquid in the curry but have very thick gravy around the meat. They’re both appear to be in red color due to the red chili used in the curry paste. They both use coconut milk as a base.

Second, their differences. In Kaeng Panang, there would be meat and poultry such as chicken, beef, pork, lamb, or duck. So it makes sense that Kaeng Panang contains spices, because Thai people do not like the smell of cooked land animal and try to cover it up with spice. They will cook Panang by boiling the curry with the meat and simmer it until the meat is tender and the curry is reduced to gravy thickness, then dress it with chiffonaded kaffir lime leaves.

Kaeng Choo Chee, on the other hand, is usually found with fish, shrimp or other seafood. The seafood would be poached, wok-fried, steam or dipped in batter and deep-fried like tempura, before Choo Chee curry gravy would be poured over at the end. So, the Choo Chee curry would be cooked separately, seasoned until ready before pairing it with the already cooked seafood, just like a dressing or sauce. Also Kaeng Choo Chee will be finished with chiffonaded kaffir lime leaves as well.

At a certain Thai restaurants both in Thailand and outside, you might see Panang and Choo Chee with Thai basil wilted in the gravy, but traditional Thai cooks will not put Thai basil (Ho-ra-pa) inside the curry, but instead serve fresh basil on the side or at the closest is put on top as decorative (still fresh and obviously not cooked with the curry) so you can chew on it to get the fresh taste.

Please, do not ask me why Thai basil isn’t suppose to be put in the Choo Chee or Panang gravy. I don’t have the answer. I’ve been asking for at least three and a half decades! Have you ever though why don’t people cut baloney (balogna sausage) into about half-inch thickness and put it in a burger bun then call it a hotdog? Or why don’t they shape ground beef into a stick instead of a patty, grill it, put it in a hotdog bun then call it a burger? I guess the only answer is “Tradition”, putting all these types of questions in the same pile!

Now you might be interested to know more about Kaeng Phed and Kaeng Pa. I use almost the same curry paste to make both curries, even though I might add more white peppercorn to the Kaeng Pa, but that doesn’t amount to much. My family’s recipe is slightly different than mine. They will add more fresh red chilies to the Kaeng Pa curry paste, together with the white peppercorn. (NOW you know why my recipe is different than my family.) They’re both using the same curry paste but they appear to be totally different because they use the different base.

Kaeng Phed is the coconut-based curry soup with a milder taste and aroma. Of course it’s milder than Kaeng Pa—it’s cooked in coconut milk! Coconut milk already masks some of the pungent smell of the curry paste. It has meat and vegetables in the curry and is finished with Thai basil (wilted in the curry.)

Kaeng Pa, or Jungle curry (Pa=jungle) is the water-based curry soup, or you might want to call it a soup base, but I never use soup stock to make it. It also has many more fresh herbs and vegetables too. Fingerroot, young peppercorn or green peppercorn are normally  in the ingredients of the Kaeng Pa, and this curry isn’t finished with Thai basil like Kaeng Phed, but uses hot and spicy Holy basil instead, together with other pungent vegetables. You will know more about the “options” when I dedicate a whole blog to the Kaeng Pa recipe. We’re merely scratching the surface with just the curry paste right now.

Don’t worry, you will get plenty of examples and recipes in subsequent posts.

Now that you understand that Kaeng Panaeng and Kaeng Choo Chee are gravy-like curries, and Kaeng Pa is the water base curry soup, then we can talk about Kaeng Kua and Kaeng Phed, which appear to be similar in color and both are coconut based. From the different names, you can safely guess that they’re not exactly the same, but how?

Kaeng Phed (Phed=spicy or hot) curry paste contains “spices”–cumin and coriander seeds—and in some other household recipes might contain even more than these two, such as clove, mace or nutmeg)—but Kaeng Kua doesn’t contain them. (Also, some households wouldn’t even put coriander root in their Kaeng Kua curry paste). That’s would be the first differentiation. Then there are more. Kaeng Kua normally would contain dried fish or dried shrimp in the curry paste, but that is still optional.

Also, ingredients in Kaeng Phed dishes in general would have more meat than vegetables, but Kaeng Kua ingredients normally would be more vegetables than meat. Another difference is Kaeng Phed will be salty with a hint of coconut milk, sweet and never sour, but Kaeng Kua might be salty with sourness sometimes, depending on the vegetables added to the curry. The sourness usually comes from the vegetables, fruits or tamarind paste.

Don’t get discouraged yet. You will learn them one by one and, at the end, you will understand Thai curries thoroughly, almost like you were born eating them every day at home ;)

Okay, since you understand the principle of each curry, let’s make a curry paste. The first one of course will be the Choo Chee curry.

These ingredients are enough to make a bowl of curry for one or two servings:

From left: Kaeng Kua curry paste 1st row ingredients for Kaeng Phed (from top: white peppercorn, coriander seeds and cumin seeds) 2nd row ingredients for Kaeng Choo Chee (from top: roasted coconut flake, white peppercorn) 3rd row ingredients for Kaeng Panaeng (from top: roasted peanuts, white peppercorn, coriander seeds and cumin seeds, sliced shallots 4th row ingredients for Kaeng Pa (from top: fresh red chili, white peppercorn, coriander seeds and cumin seeds.

From left: Kaeng Kua curry paste
1st row ingredients for Kaeng Phed (from top: white peppercorn, coriander seeds and cumin seeds)
2nd row ingredients for Kaeng Choo Chee (from top: roasted coconut flake, white peppercorn)
3rd row ingredients for Kaeng Panang (from top: roasted peanuts, white peppercorn, coriander seeds and cumin seeds, sliced shallots
4th row ingredients for Kaeng Pa (from top: fresh red chili, white peppercorn, coriander seeds and cumin seeds.

Ingredients for Kaeng Choo Chee curry paste

Kaeng Kua curry paste 1/4 cup

White pepper 1 teaspoon

Roasted coconut flake 2 tablespoons

Method for Kaeng Choo Chee curry paste

Mush the pepper until finely ground

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 13

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 14

then add roasted coconut flakes

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 15

and pound on them until they break down, but not as finely as the pepper.

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 16

Add Kaeng Kua curry paste to the mortar and mix them. The Choo Chee curry paste is ready.

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 17

Ingredients for Kaeng Panang curry paste

Kaeng Kua curry paste 1/4 cup

White pepper 1/2 teaspoon

Shallots sliced 1 tablespoon

Roasted peanuts 2 tablespoon (roasted Mung bean is another substitute)

Roasted cumin 1/2 teaspoon

Roasted coriander seed 1 teaspoon

Method for Kaeng Panang curry paste

Mush all the spices first until they are finely ground, including the pepper.

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 11

Then add the shallots

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 19

and pound until they’re all mushed with no chunks left to be seen.

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 20

Add the roasted peanuts

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 21

and crack them until they’re ground, but we’re not making peanut butter here so don’t pound them too hard.

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 22

Add the Kaeng Kua curry paste to the mortar and mix all of them well. This is your Panang curry paste.

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 23

Ingredients for Kaeng Phed curry paste

Kaeng Kua curry paste 1/4 cup

White pepper 1 teaspoon

Roasted cumin 1/2 teaspoon

Roasted coriander seed 1 teaspoon

Method for Kaeng Phed curry paste

Same as the above; mush all the spices and pepper until they are finely ground and add the Kaeng Kua curry paste to the mortar and mix. That’s it!

Ingredients for Kaeng Pa curry paste

Kaeng Kua curry paste 1/4 cup

White pepper 2 teaspoons

Roasted cumin 1/2 teaspoon

Roasted coriander seed 1 teaspoon

Fresh red pepper;  I used 1 whole jalapeño red pepper (This is optional. If you like it very spicy then, add more or add the spicier pepper like Thai chili or bird’s- eye chili. I even de-seeded the baby jalapeño chili for my own curry!

Method for Kaeng Pa curry paste

Same method; mush all the spices and pepper until they are finely ground,

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 25

then add the fresh chili

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 26

and mush them coarsely. The jungle curry doesn’t need the fine curry paste like most other curry. Then add the Kaeng Kua curry paste and just mix them.

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 27

Now you have all four curry pastes as easy as that. Please keep in mind that all the Thai curry paste ingredients are not carved in stone. You can start from here and you can adjust later on. Each family has a different approach. This is my own take on it. I like it this way. Some other family might add or subtract some minor ingredients, because their balance preference is different, but before you add ingredients that I didn’t list here, it would be best to go back to my first curry paste episode about what is not supposed to be in Thai curry paste, just to make sure.

In the restaurants in Bangkok these days, I hardly ever found Panang with roasted peanuts or roasted mung beans, or Choo Chee with roasted coconut flakes in their curry pastes. I think the pre-made curry pastes and the Thai-style fast food restaurant, “Rhan Khao Kaeng”, that is all over the country, is responsible. Well, if you really want to point the finger, the lack of interest to create their own or even carry on the family recipe by the Baby Boomers and Gen Xs is the core of the cause.

As I remember, my mother rarely spent time in the kitchen. She was working. My nanny is the one who cooked for the whole family. She was from Issan, the northeastern part of Thailand, so she knew almost nothing about cooking non-Issan dishes. My grandmother, together with my dad, taught her how to cook anything beyond making Som Tam, Larb  and other Issan dishes. Since my grandmother taught her, she learned the traditional way of cooking curries and all the other Bangkok and Southern dishes.

My mother would buy pre-made curry paste from the market (of course full potentcy heat from chilies, Thai style). But because I couldn’t eat spicy food but wanted to enjoy “adult” food, my nanny was forced to make curry paste the traditional way, minus the chilies, so her “Khun Noo” (little brat, me) can eat curry.

Later on, when I expressed interest in cooking Thai food, mostly because I came to school overseas and I needed to learn survival skills, my nanny was a good source of information, along with my dad. This is not the same path that most of my Gen X friends took.

Most of my friends, the Gen X, rarely paid attention to Thai cooking. Why? Because restaurants and street vendors are all over Bangkok. They didn’t growing up eating home-cooked meals anyway, because their parents, the baby boomers, were so busy working. If they ever tasted a home-cooked meal, it would have been from their grandma or the hired cooks, the helpers at home that made the meals. The majority of them know and had eaten curry all their lives, but if you ask them to make curry paste from scratch, they probably can’t do it. They rely heavily on the pre-made curry pastes.

With regard to the pre-made curry paste, certain ingredients like roasted coconut or roasted peanuts shorten the shelf life of the pastes, so the merchants wouldn’t want to put them in their curry paste. When I was young and the pre-made curry pastes were just a new thing in Thailand, the merchant didn’t even put shrimp paste in the pre-made! This was before they learned to sterilize the paste. The protein in the shrimp paste could have spoiled the curry paste and reduced the shelf life considerably.

Back in the day, the housewife who was advanced enough to use pre-made curry paste knew to mush shrimp paste into the paste before cooking with it. These days, when the pre-made curry paste already include shrimp paste, they’re quite complete. Some of them are ready to be used right away, such as the most popular Kaeng Phed (Red curry), Kaeng Khiao Wan (Green curry), and Kaeng Masaman, which is the most complicated curry. So the cooks in the “Khao Kaeng” restaurant probably don’t know to “re-work” the paste by putting roasted coconut in Choo Chee curry paste or putting roasted peanuts in Panang curry paste. That’s my assumption.

Another assumption is the roasted coconut or roasted peanuts are “optional ingredients” for some households. The Choo Chee curry paste at my house, normally didn’t have galangal and cilantro root in the curry paste, but at my uncle’s house his wife put galangal, cilantro and fingerroot but didn’t put roasted coconut in it.

The Panang curry paste recipe I gave you is my own invention. My grandmother would cut the amount of garlic in the curry paste if she made Panaeng. She would not only put roasted mung beans in the curry paste (because it was something readily available in her kitchen at all times, unlike peanuts that she had to specifically buy), but she also put turmeric in it, too.

Are you confused enough now?  Each household has their own balance, but the ingredients wouldn’t differ from the handful of the ingredients I already gave you, even though the amount of each ingredient might vary.

Authentic Advance Thai curry paste 31

Eventually, you will develop your own or relax about “HOW MUCH” you should put of each ingredient into your curry paste. As long as you stop clicking on the “ABOUT something I don’t know well but want to share.com” site, then you will be fine.

Please, remember that “Ketchup” is NOT an ingredient in Thai curry paste, no matter how many non-Thai who pretend to know Thai food or have written a cookbook or two about foods that look like Thai foods (but they’re actually not) try to tell you.  You won’t get Thai people to appreciate your curry if you add even a dash of it in. I mean only the polite Thai people will just “not appreciate” your added ketchup, but li’l ol’ me…hell yeah…I would barf it out right in front of you!

Next week I will show you how to apply the Choo Chee curry paste to a seafood dish.


40 Comments on “Thai Curry Episode VII: Advance Authentic Thai Red Curry Paste, Kaeng Panang, Kaeng ChuChee, Kaeng Phed and Jungle Curry Paste”

  1. Dee says:

    This is the MOTHER of all websites related to serious thai cooking. my family loves thai food and this website has allowed me to cook great food for them. I greatly appreciate the time you have spent explaining everything in such detail, I learned a lot from you. thank you.

  2. […] is a curry paste that uses fresh chili in the paste, unlike most of the other curry pastes I’ve given you the recipes for (except the green curry paste, of course). Southern curry paste […]

  3. […] with meat and poultry, and is supposed to be a thick curry rather than a soup-like curry. Check out The High Heel Gourmet for more about advanced curry […]

  4. […] from the beginning. We just added the “spices”, (remember what we consider as spice from my earlier blog) after we adapted the Indian curry to our […]

  5. becky6259 says:

    Your posts are so informational and easy to understand — the pictures you post with the instructions are super helpful — you make it look so easy!

  6. Your Thai dishes always looks so delicious! But they sound like so much work that I’m a bit scared of attempting them… =\

    • Come on…you can do anything if you put your heart to it. Writing a blog (with my poor English it is harder than making a Thai dish from scratch for me, you know) is so much harder. It’s a fun project for your free time too. ;)

  7. dfen911 says:

    I just had to reblog this. It’s a wonderful source of information! Thank you :) oregongreenacres.wordpress.com

  8. dfen911 says:

    Reblogged this on Our Green Acres and commented:
    I must say that curry is something I have not mastered (yet). But after reading this blog entry I am now not as intimidated as I once was. The details, information and recipes provided made me HUNGRY! Now that’s a good food blog :) I hope you all enjoy it as much as I did.

  9. topa says:

    Mouthwatering! :-)

  10. Mustang.Koji says:

    You do make it easy. Great documentation!

  11. susieu says:

    You are a wonderful teacher ka! Kaeng pa is going to be on my dinner menu this week now for sure :) thank u!

  12. Miranti, I really love your food and blog. This is another wonderful tutorial. I’m always learning something every time I visit. Once again, very nicely done.

  13. chefmo73 says:

    I like this post. A lot. I will be spending a lot of time here.

  14. AJ says:

    I have often made a large batch of curry paste and put the extra in a small glass mason jar, topped it off with a neutral flavored oil, just enough to cover, and put it in refrigerator until I need it next. The oil prevents air from penetrating the paste which prevents bacteria from growing.

    • The method is widely used to preserve other Thai ingredients such as Nam Phrik Pao or Thai chili jam but obviously NOT for the fresh Thai curry paste or else you would see authentic Thai curry paste preserved that way.

      In fact you would see most of them (one that export from Thailand or made by the Thais) sterilized by steaming and packed in package for sell just like that.

      The reason is the usage. Not all Thai curry pastes would be used by frying with oil. If you read my previous posts, the Thai fried fish cake, Tod Mun, the Thai fish mouse, Hor Mok did not use the “cooked” curry paste. If the curry paste touch oil and the oil goes in the fish cake, the fish cake would fall apart at the worst and soggy at the best (believe it or not because the cake will be fried in oil!) and the fish mouse would have the same symptom.

      There are many more Thai curry pastes that are cooked without frying in oil. In fact we don’t even fry them in oil originally, we fry them in coconut milk that has some oil (coconut oil) on top. That curry rely so heavily on the freshness of the ingredients in the curry paste so Thai people wouldn’t sacrifice that freshness for shelf life.

      I have my inventive way to “extend” the life of the curry paste but as I stated it before, I normally used them up pretty quickly because store them for a long time isn’t the purpose of making fresh curry paste. I don’t like how it taste after it past over two weeks! (NONE of my family member approves my “extended life” curry paste already. They always ask if my curry paste is fresh when I cook for them. They thought that I’m such a lazy cook!)

  15. So much I never knew about curry! I only knew it was delicious before :)

  16. Cocino Thai says:

    Excellent post, the best written about thai curry !

    • Thanks! I wish I can write or speak Spanish too. There are a lot of Latino in Los Angeles who LOVE Thai food and want to learn how to cook them but I can’t teach them in Spanish. My house keeper who don’t speak a lot of English begging to learn how to make Kaeng Phed and Tom Yum. So, I taught her to cook with very little words and I sent her daughter a link to your blog.

      Thanks that I’ve found your blog naka even though I don’t understand the words but the pictures are beautiful and at least I have a place where I can send Spanish speaking people to learn Thai cooking.

      • Cocino Thai says:

        Thank you so much ka, i’m so glad and happy about it. Even though here in Spain is a little bit dificult to find many Thai ingredients, I am trying to do my best in order the spanish and also latino people learn and taste Thai food. Greeting from spain ka.

  17. dfen911 says:

    What a wonderful education on curry! I love the idea of starting with one and tuning it for your needs. Thank you for this wonderful info! :)

  18. Hans Susser says:

    The best written, most charming, most informative article on curry I’ve ever read.
    Thank you Miranti :-)

  19. Your images are always so beautiful, and you have a knack for making the difficult look simple. Thanks.

  20. Wow thank you for this post – it’s so helpful! I’ve learnt so much in 15 minutes! I will be back to refer to this when I attempt to make my own curry from scratch. :) x

  21. saucygander says:

    This is so useful! I have bookmarked this post!

  22. Conor Bofin says:

    Really elegant post. The flavours from an authentic paste are totally different to anything one can buy in a jar. Keep up te great work.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 6,047 other followers